MOGADISHU — Somalia’s State Minister for Foreign Affairs, Ali Omar (Ali Balcad), has sparked political debate after claiming that Puntland has historically failed to cooperate with successive Federal Government administrations, arguing that the current tensions with President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud are nothing new.
Speaking about the longstanding political disagreements between Puntland and the Federal Government, Ali Balcad said Puntland had experienced strained relations with several previous Somali presidents, including Abdiqasim Salad Hassan, Sheikh Sharif Sheikh Ahmed and Mohamed Abdullahi Farmaajo.
“Puntland did not cooperate with Abdiqasim, did not cooperate with Sharif, and did not cooperate with Farmaajo. Therefore, this is nothing new, nor is it something unique to Hassan,” Ali Balcad said.
Minister Says Political Disagreements Are Not Limited to Hassan Sheikh’s Administration
The minister’s remarks appear to challenge arguments that the current political confrontation between Puntland and Mogadishu is primarily the result of policies pursued by President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud’s administration.
By referring to previous federal governments, Balcad suggested that disagreements between Puntland and successive administrations have been a recurring feature of Somalia’s federal political system.
His comments also raise questions about the nature of relations between Somalia’s central government and its federal member states, particularly regarding political authority, constitutional arrangements and the distribution of powers.
Longstanding Tensions Between Mogadishu and Garowe
Relations between Puntland and the Federal Government have repeatedly deteriorated over disagreements involving constitutional amendments, electoral arrangements, federal authority and the implementation of national political agreements.
Puntland has consistently emphasized its constitutional powers and administrative autonomy, while successive federal administrations have sought to strengthen national institutions and advance their respective political agendas.
These disagreements have, at various times, resulted in political boycotts, the suspension of cooperation and public confrontations between federal and regional leaders.
Remarks Likely to Fuel Political Debate
Ali Balcad’s statement is likely to generate further debate within Somalia’s political circles, particularly among supporters and critics of the current federal administration.
His comments present the ongoing dispute as part of a broader historical pattern rather than an isolated disagreement between Puntland and President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud.
However, the statement may also raise questions about why successive federal administrations have struggled to establish lasting political cooperation with Puntland and other federal member states.
Federalism and Somalia’s Political Future
The recurring disagreements between Mogadishu and Garowe highlight the broader challenges facing Somalia’s federal system, which continues to grapple with questions of constitutional interpretation, political representation, power-sharing and institutional authority.
Political analysts have frequently identified cooperation between the Federal Government and federal member states as essential to strengthening national institutions, maintaining political stability and advancing Somalia’s state-building process.
The key question remains whether Somalia’s political leadership can move beyond recurring confrontations and establish a sustainable federal relationship based on constitutional clarity, mutual trust and meaningful political cooperation.











